C R I S I S I N C L E R G Y A U T H O R I T Y:
“The Clergy Killer Phenomenon”
The epic of Christendom is no stranger to attacks and crises. However, while most previous attacks originated externally and left clergy relatively unscathed, our contemporary crisis is unique in originating from within a congregation and focusing on the clergy. The Clergy Killer Phenomenon features vulnerable clergy and small numbers of lay persons terrorizing pastors.
The attacks by laity, resulting in devastated clergy and widespread collateral damage may legitimately be designated “spiritual warfare.” Spiritual warfare is identified by its participants, their motivations and the massive interference with God’s purposes for the church. The participants are clergy unprepared for bold and persistent attacks on their authority and ministry, their personhood, and anyone near to them. The motivation of the antagonists is to cause elimination of the pastor through character assassination and anguish, while the pastor strives to survive without benefit of adequate training, support and freedom to fight back. The interference with God’s purposes for the pastor and congregation are so intimidating that parishioners are confused, intimidated and may leave the church.
Consequences of these terroristic attacks have ripple effects beyond the congregation and its pastor. Denominational officials are forced to choose between unwanted responses while parishioners must choose sides, church polity is weakened, and the morality of the community and nation is compromised as part of this phenomenon. Damage has reached such high proportions that the church and its pastors must now learnand use the legitimate spiritual resources available in spiritual warfare.
The “authority” of clergy was and is dependecnt upon the tradition and mystique of the role, the validation of the selected person by legitimate training institutions in organized religion, appropriate fr this role, a source book of polity and theology, denominational and congregational support, a decorum for the pastor’s daily life, and a respected position in the community/nation. When any one of these supports is weakened or missing, clergy authority, perceived and real, is weakened, and she becomes vulnerable to personal disrespect and and attack. Presently we are learning that not only have all of these clergy supports been weakened, but the weakened and unsupported pastors are under abusive attack by persons who have given themselves, consciously or unconsciously, to the elimination of not only the pastor’s authority, but that of his personhood and supporters as well. With the loss of all these supports, and the growth of abuse, many anguished pastors are feeling FORSAKEN & BETRAYED.
Multiple causes have produced this potent social phenomenon, some more signifcant than others. The clergy sex scandsls and permissive decorum of the 1980-90x are a prime case of clergy giving cause to question the validity of their authority. The exposed politics of denominational operations, and decline in the decline in church membership also lessen authority. However, the major external causes are the “question authority” and “entitlement” in USA attitudes, and loss of fear concerning spiritual spiritual issues.
CAUTION: CLERGY BLUNDERS AND SCANDALS GIVE NO EXCUSE TO SCANDALIZE, ABUSE AND ELIMINATE NORMALLY FUNCTIONING CLERGY!
PROFILES OF THE CLERGY KILLER PHENOMENON
(For more complete discussion, vid. my book CLERGY KILLERS)
Profile of Society’s, Congregation’s, Denomination’s, Pastor’s, VULNERABILITIES…
Society: Questioning of Authority Prevalent; Moral Sensitivities Dulled; Economic Confusion, Duress (International Coflict & Confusion; Technological/Scientific Transformations; International Spirituality Revisions/Interactions, Political Influences; Unhealthy Lifestyles Prevalent
Congregation: Traditions Disregarded; Age/gender/racial/denominational identity; “Cafeteria” Attitude; Frequent Conflict; Financial Stress; Loss of Respect for Clergy; Influences of the “Emergent” (new) spirituality/worship styles; Loss of Mission Relevancies; Biblical Illiteracy; Inadequate Training of Lay Leaders; Poor Organization; Unawareness/Apathy Regarding The Clergy Killers Phenomenon & Abusive Conflict
Denominational: Decline in Membership/Finances; Dominance of Denominational Politics; Confusion/Lack of Concern Regarding Bullying of Pastors; Impact of Sex Scandals; Denominational/Interreligious Interactions; Influences of New Congregaional Styles
Clergy: Loss of Respect for Clergy Role; Loss of Denominational Support; Confusion Regarding the Role of Pastor; Ineffective Seminary Training & Support; Impact of “The Clergy Killer Phenomenon;” Severe Changes Clergy Statistics; Clergy Family Disorientations
Types of Conflicts in Congregations & Religions (everyday designations are used for clarity)
Normal Conflict: Common, Ordinarily Respectful & Honest, Open to Resolution:
Remedy I: NEGOTIATION & Structured Dialogue
Remedy II: MEDIATION (A Solution Recommended Following Discussion); ARBITRATION (A Solution Is Mandated)
Abnormal Conflict: Disagreements & Disorder Perpetrated by One Intransigent or Impaired Person Or Group,
Remedy: Best Handled by “Tough Love” Methods, Disciplines Healing Practices, Followed by Installation of Immunization Protocols
Spiritual Conflict/Warfare: The Incursion of EVIL Into a Congregation, Through One or Several Persons Who Have Given Themselves to EVIL Motivations, Purposes & Tactics, in Which Nothing Is Viewed As Sacrosanct & No Terrorist Activity Unthinkable.
Remedy: Intervention by Appropriate & Empowered Leaders, Through Whom Resoultion Is Initiated & Pursued Till a Righteous Solution Applied, by Appropriate Application of “Immunization Methods” (q.v.), “Instruments of Peace” (q.v.), Spiritually Disciplined Exorcism, Legally Derived Civil Court Orders or Remedies, and Followed by Spiritually Relevant Healing & Resumption of Normal Congregational Health Practices.
PROFILES OF “CLERGY KILLERS”
Identies: “Behaviorly Challenged Persons” (Non-cooperative); Arrogant/Domineering Attitudes; Disrespectful of Leaders; Aggressive; Recruits Followers; Persistent; Terroristic Attitude
Functional Identifications; Deluded; Destructive; Determined; Deceitful; Diabolical (clever, conniving); Discipling (the 6 D’s). Seldom rehabilitated
Possible Maladaptive Disorders: Antisocial Personality Disorder (Sociopathic); Borderline Personality Disorder; Narcissistic Personality Disorder; Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder; Histrionic Personality Disorder; Substance Dependence/Abuse Disorder; Adult Children of Substance Abusers, Intellectually Impaired; Behaviorally Challenged.
Patterns of the Clergy Killer Phenomenon (usually progressive): Unhealthy Congregational Leadership; Deteriorating Relationship with Pastor/Supporters; Sustained Negativity; Attacks on Pastor: Innuendoes, Demands, Threats; Bypasses Corrective Barriers; Abuses Pastor/Family/Supporters; Opens Multiple Fronts in Attacks/Abuse; Introduces Traumatic Abuses; Induces Terroristic Damages; Flaunts Evil Effects; Demonstrates Victories; Lays Groundwork for Abusing Next Pastor
Deterioration of Pastor (with Related Declines in Family/Supporters:
I. SURPRISE is common, as victims can hardly believe the CKP is happening to them. For they do not think of themselves as deserving such audacious & malicious attacks, & they were untrained by seminary & denomination to expect this.
II. QUESTIONING often follows surprise, for we typically feel compelled to unt tor such maliciousness: “Why me?” “What did I do to deserve this?” “Why is God letting this happen?” “Who will support/save me?” etc.
III. ANXIOUS FLOUNDERING is a natural effort to resolve, seek help, & escape the escalating brutalization. Inappropriate & unhealthy coping mechanisms often begin to occur in this stage. It is obvious then that typically the pastor is forced to engage in this warfare without much appropriate training, & even with training & experience she/he is handicapped, while a CK feels free to use any weapons to abuse & force the pastor’s departure.
IV. The COLLATERAL DAMAGE-INFECTION becomes apparent to pastors as their family suffers, denominations are unsupportive, parishioners become confused & angry, & as questioning, apathy, loss of faith, & departures become common.
V. DEPRESSION in the form of intense anxiety, desperate bravado, incriminations, and/or a sense of inevitable doom envelops the pastor, despair, while well-intentioned supporters flounder & others are bewildered or apathetic. NOTE: such depression may last as PTSD, beyond a return to seemingly normal life.
IMMUNIZATIONS & DEFENSES REGARDING “THE CLERGY KILLER PHENOMENON:”
SELF-AWARENESS & SELF-CARE (Paying effective attention to real self & state of health) This is not self-centeredness)
AWARENESS of Current Upheavals/Disorientations/Consequences; AWARENESS of Spiritual Warfare; AWARENESS of Remedies
AWARENESS of changes in leadership styles/motivations; negative vs positive perspectives; Types of Conflict & Appropriate Management; Need for Healthy Relationships & Shared Responsibilities; Need for Development of a Plan A, Plan B, Plan C… in handling change & difficulties;
AWARENESS & PRACTICE OF EXPANDED SPIRITUALITY & ENERGY MANAGEMENT (See description of this crucial factor in my book: The Toxic Congregation)
DEVELOPMENT of “Instruments of Peace” for Professional & Congregational Conflict Management, Healing & Growth, Such as:
“The Grievance-Suggestion Procedure (see full explanation of this program, & the following Instruments of Peace in my book THE TOXIC CONGREGATION)
Leadership Training in Conflict Management & Spiritual Development, with specialized training regarding the Spiritual-Mental Disease/Sickness Known as “The Clergy Killer Phenomenon.”
Periodic Practice of Membership Vows & Renewal, in order to keep parishioners conscious of the benefits, responsibilities, & disciplines of membership.
Build Support for Pastor(s), as normal function of a dedicated congregation
Study/Practice of the Realities of the Forgiveness, Healing, & Reconciliation Triad (It Should Be Emphasized That the Decision of a Victim of the CKP Is a Difficult & Extended Response to Abuse. The Clergy Killer Is Unlikely to Sincerely Ask for Forgiveness. Therefore the Victim Must Accept Responsibility For Persistent Decisions to Continue Forgiving the Perpetrator, Developing the Needed, Slow Self-Healing That Needs Therapeutic Support & Consistent Spiritual Blessings. It Should Be Noted That Such Forgiveness Is Not Readily possible or beneficial for All Victims. Also, a Decision to Forgive May Aid Parishioners, But Does Not Create Forgiveness & Healing in Them, Unless Each Person Chooses This Remedy. Further, It Should Be Noted That Forgiveness Does Not Automatically Generate Reconciliation Between Aggrieved Parties. In Fact, Attempts At Reconciliation Between Victim(s) & CKs Typically Results in a Second Victimization, & Does Little to Promote Healing & Repair Damage–Nor is It Likely to Change the CK. And, Since Such Forgiveness Is Not the Same As Justice & Reparations, Forgiveness Does Not Necessarily Produce Peace, Healing & Recovery. For Justice, Reparations, Reconciliation, & Peace to Prevail, Competent Therapy, Spiritual Ministries, & Legal Issues Must Be Considered.)
Development of Healing Ministries (These Must Be Applied In Spiritually-Mentally-Physically Competent Ways, & Often Require Reinforcing Ministrations.)
Prayer Circles & Experience-Sharing Groups
Establishing a “Listening Post” Function in Regular Settings & Practices (a competent person who will be present after worship services to hear parishioner’s grievances & positive suggestions)
Developing Groupings, Programs, & Study of This Congregation’s “Soul” (It’s History, Environmental Influences, Resources, Identities/Stories, Missions, & Possibilities).
Reinvent & Reinforce the Congregation’s Mission Development, Internal Self-Care of Members, & the Congregation’s “Soul” (Individual & corporate identities, capabilities & needs).
THINK3
I have a dream…too. I dream that global transformations will continue until the vast majority of human persons will have developed the magnifying thought process we can designate THINK3. This is the third and most expansive level of thinking we have yet discovered. It involves mind-spirit-body in an expanding awareness of our universal existence, and the amplification of universal participation in an exploding cosmic creation. Level One in thinking is our normal use of consciousness. Level Two is the occasional burst of mental creativity that lifts us temporarily above Level One to “thinking outside the box.” Both of the first two levels happen of their own accord. THINK3 (from here on T-3), however, requires conscious imaginative thinking without a box. How is this possible?
{This concept will be followed by a full essay soon}
Posted by glrediger